OLOL Back in The News

Yet again, Our Lady of Lourdes Hospital in Drogheda is in the news for all the wrong reasons. According to Fiach Kelly in today’s Irish Independent, when Melissa Redmond presented for an early pregnancy scan, the doctor who performed the scan told her and her husband that their baby was dead. Arrangements were made for Melissa to undergo a D&C operation to remove the foetus from her womb.

Melissa, however, who already had two children and had also suffered four miscarriages, felt that this was a misdiagnosis. Relying on her own instinct and previous experiences, she made an appointment with her GP, who confirmed that her foetus was still very much alive.

Melissa gave birth to a healthy boy in March of this year.  As her husband,  Michael,  says in the Indo’s report today, there is every possibility that other women could have had viable foetuses removed from their wombs. Unfortunately – in a culture where doctors are still treated as gods – it is not just possible, it is highly likely. As there will be no investigation by the hospital, just how many babies – if any – have been killed by negligent doctors at OLOL in Drogheda will never be known.

A number of things struck me about this case.

Firstly, I was shocked that one doctor – without a second opinion or reference to a single colleague – declared a baby dead and set about organising the removal of said baby from his mother’s womb. Surely, a second opinion should have been sought?

Secondly, it brings glaringly into focus that midwifery skills are sorely lacking in Irish hospitals. A competent midwife with a functioning pinard would have been able to tell Melissa the happy news that her baby was fine.  No piece of equipment can take the place of an experienced midwife.

Although it wasn’t mentioned in the newspaper article, I have to wonder if the doctor asked Melissa Redmond such obvious, common-sense questions as ‘Do you still feel pregnant?’ or any question relating to how she felt at the time of the scan and how she felt on previous occasions when she lost a baby. Contrary to what so many members of the medical profession seem to think, women are not thick – not even when they are pregnant – and asking relevant questions can uncover relevant answers.

Once again, I was struck by how badly women and children are treated in Irish society. I was struck by how little we matter – and how disempowered we are (even though I sometimes wonder if women are their own worst enemy and actively collude in their own suppression – but that’s a blog entry for another day).

The bottom line, I think, is that women need to take more responsibility for their own health and well-being – whether that’s taking responsibility by choosing the safer option of a home birth (homebirth is safer than hospital birth for over 80% of women) or by simply trusting her own instinct and asking for a second opinion.

Published by

Hazel Katherine Larkin


6 thoughts on “OLOL Back in The News”

  1. Agree with you, maternity care here leaves a lot to be desired, although I had a lovely young female doctor through my 2 pregnancies and she was totally on the ball.
    I heard the mum ‘Melissa’ on the Pat Kenny radio show today and the story was made all the more incredible as you could hear the baby gurgling in the background – amiracle he’s here at all.


    1. Maternity care here is shocking, Brigid, you’re right. It’s great that you had a lovely doctor when you had your two – but shocking that it’s so unusual that it’s remarkable! And women just accept it. We are so cowed and so beaten into believing that Doctor=God. Young doctors are better – or maybe I’m just more assertive and take no crap from anyone; not even those who think their first name is ‘doctor’. I remember the look of shock on a medic’s face recently when I addressed him by his first name. Well, as far as I was concerned, he had set the precedent by calling me by mine! 🙂


  2. I think you have touched on a very important topic here and one that extends beyond women and childbirth. And that is that we are all responsible for our own good health. We must take back our own power in relation to our health. Healthcare professionals WORK FOR US. We must take our power to question them, ask for second opinions and make demands. Only then will we have a health service that works for us! And one that is safer for all.

    Great passionate post


  3. With amazement today I heard another mother tell of her similar story – only her child is now happily three years old. How long has this serious misdiagnosis been going on and why has it been allowed to go on for so long?
    It’s astonishing that this has been happening for years, oh hang on – we are talking about the HSE here, I guess maybe I shouldn’t be so surprised.


Please feel free to share your thoughts and comments!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.